Indexical Identification: A Perspectival Account
نویسنده
چکیده
It is widely agreed that the references of indexical expressions are fixed partly by their relations to contextual parameters such as the author, time, and place of the utterance. Because of this, indexicals are sometimes described as token-reflexive or utterance-reflexive in their semantics. But when we inquire into how indexicals help us to identify items within experience, we find that while utterance-reflexivity is essential to an interpretation of indexical tokens, it is not a factor in a speaker’s identificatory use of indexicals. Tokens cannot be interpreted unless they are first produced, and obviously the speaker who produces them does not depend upon utterance parameters in order to identify their referents in the way that hearers do. Consequently, the standard reflexive accounts of indexicals are of little use in explaining the speaker’s identificatory use of indexicals, and must be either replaced or complemented by a further theory of the role of indexicals in thought. This paper provides an account of indexical identification that is attentive to a speaker’s as well as a hearer’s identification and reveals how indexicals are inextricably perspectival.
منابع مشابه
Perspective, logophoricity, and embedded tense in Japanese
The organization of the paper is as follows. In Section 2, I review the two major approaches to Japanese tenses in past studies, i.e. the “uniform/non-indexical” approach (e.g. Ogihara 1996) and the “non-uniform/indexical” approach (e.g. Oshima 2006a), drawing on data that involve tenses in matrix clauses and in complement clauses (of utterance/attitude predicates).1 In Section 3, I consider te...
متن کاملPoints of View from the Brain's Eye View: Subjectivity and Neural Representation
Conscious experiences are supposed by many to be subjective in the sense of being perspectival or from a point-of-view (see, for example Nagel 1974, 1986 and Tye 1995). Allegedly, the subjectivity of consciousness is beyond the grasp of science, which is objective (Nagel 1986). If you wanted a scientific understanding of consciousness, how would you solve the problem of subjectivity? One strate...
متن کاملMeaning and Justification of Direction and Change of Direction in Perceptual Space
The paper presents a case study in the compositionality of particle-motionverbs. Part of the investigation is the interaction between indexical elements contributed by hin(there, thither) vs. her(here, hither) and the deictic motion verbs kommen (come) vs. gehen (go). The investigation will lead to a distinction between the notion indexical in the sense of ’direct reference to the utterance sit...
متن کاملStructure of Perspectivity: A Case of Japanese Reflexive Pronoun “dwP
Yasuhiro Katagiri NTT Basic Research Laboratories Midori-cho, Musashino, Tokyo, 180 Japan katagiri%[email protected] A theory of perspectivity is proposed to establish the foundation of the theory of situated agents. An account is then given, based on the theory of perspectivity, of the use of a seemingly perspectivity related expression, Japanese long-range reflexive “zibun. ” The theor...
متن کاملPerspectival Discourse Referents for Indexicals
By definition, the reference of an indexical depends on the context of utterance. For example, the proposition expressed by I am hungry depends on who says this and when. Since Kaplan (1979), context dependence has been analyzed in terms of two parameters: an utterance context, which determines the reference of indexicals, and a formally unrelated assignment function, which determines the refer...
متن کامل